logo
I launched this website just to help YOU with choosing an appropriate mattress, pillow and other sleeping equipment for better sleeping. WHY? Because It`s a crucial part of life and EVERYONE has to sleep comfortably and wake up refreshed. JOIN ME and get always fresh reviews, coupons and monthly giveaways!

JOIN ME for the new reviews
coupons and monthly giveaways!

Fell Free To contact Me
If YOU have any questions, recommendations, remarks, offers or something else, do not hesitate to WRITE ME AN E-MAIL. You can find my e-mail below.
Top

Ah, who doesn’t love a nice, delicious breakfast in bed, with a cup of hot coffee and a glass of orange juice?

Sounds lovely, right?

And who doesn’t love trying to remove juice stains from a mattress costing $2,000?

No one. No one loves that.

So, to save your mattress from being soaked and you from emptying your wallet when buying a new one, I’ve gathered 7 top mattress protectors. Let’s see, which one can become the best safeguard for your bed.

Mattress Protector

“A mattress protector, especially when it’s a waterproof one, will prolong the life of your mattress and prevent it from gathering dead skin cells, sweat, and other unpleasant bits and liquids. This way, you will also protect your mattress from mold, bacteria, or mildew, and will sleep in a clean and safe environment.”

NameMaterialWarrantyRating
Bear ProtectorMain panel: 100% polyester; waterproof lining: 100% polyurethane laminate; skirt: 80% cotton + 20% polyester10 years
90%
Plushbeds Organic Cotton Mattress ProtectorTop and skirting: 100% organic cotton jersey; waterproof lining: micro-thin polyurethane5 years
95%
Brooklyn Bedding Mattress ProtectorCotton terry, polyurethane10 years
85%
Nest Bedding Cooling Mattress ProtectorTop layer: 88% polyester + 12% nylon; waterproof lining: 100% thermoplastic polyurethane; skirt: 100% polyester1 year
85%
Bedical Care Superior Mattress EncasementSurface: 100% cotton terry; waterproof lining: 100% polyurethane15 years
90%
Lucid Mattress Protector100% cotton terry surface + the waterproof Stratosmart Barrier15 years
80%
SafeRest Premium Mattress Protector
Surface: 100% cotton terry; waterproof lining: 100% polyurethane10 years
80%

Bear Protector

bear protect mattress protector
90%
Rating

This model is called “Bear Protector” for a reason: it will protect your mattress from stains, liquids, and dust as fiercely as a mama bear protects her cub. It can be called the best mattress protector simply because it does its job, and it does it well.

Here’s what you need to know about it:

  • It features the HeiQ Adaptive Fabric Technology, which makes the protector super breathable and moisture wicking.
  • It can fit mattresses that are up to 20 inches thick.
  • It is 100% waterproof.
  • The materials used include polyester, polyurethane, and cotton.
  • The manufacturer offers a 10-year warranty.

It is machine washable.

What is really great with that mattress protector?

The best thing about this mattress protector is the fact that it’s 100% waterproof and breathable at the same time. It’s not a piece of plastic, which will keep your mattress dry but will also make you sweat every night. It actually helps with temperature regulation while doing a great job, protecting your mattress.

What is wrong with that mattress protector?

The worst thing I’ve noticed about this model is the crinkly sound it made for the first couple of nights. Even though it’s not a serious issue, some people might find it irritating. Just a heads-up for you.

PROS

100% waterproof

Breathable and doesn’t sleep hot

Easy to wash

The top is soft and pleasant to the touch

Can fit almost any mattress up to 20 inches thick

CONS

Makes a crinkly sound for the first couple of nights

Might make it hard for your sheets to stay in place

Overall, I’m very happy with this top rated waterproof mattress protector. It is soft, easy to clean, and does its job quite well.

Want to try it out? Click here to order!

Plushbeds Organic Cotton Mattress Protector

Plushbeds Mattress Protector
95%
Rating

After testing out this model, I can surely say that it deserves the right to be called the best mattress protector. It is safe to use, very pleasant to the touch, and waterproof.

Let’s consider its main characteristics:

  • The top layer and the skirting are made of organic cotton, which is GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard) certified and super soft to the touch.
  • The waterproof layer is made of polyurethane, which is very thin and doesn’t make any noise.
  • It can fit mattresses up to 14 inches thick.

The manufacturer offers a 5-year warranty.

What is really great with that mattress protector?

The best thing about this mattress protector is how safe it is to use. There are no dyes, chemicals, or any other harmful components. It doesn’t smell like plastic. And yet, it effectively prevents the liquids from soaking the mattress. In my opinion, that’s all you could wish for in a mattress cover.

What is wrong with that mattress protector?

The worst thing about this model is the fact that its sides aren’t waterproof. It’s not really a huge issue, but some people might find it disappointing.

PROS

Organic and safe to use

100% waterproof top

Very pleasant to the touch

Can perfectly fit the majority of mattresses

Odor-free

Machine washable

CONS

Sides aren’t waterproof

Not an encasement type, which means it won’t protect the mattress from bed bugs

This is official: I am now a fan of this mattress protector. It is very effective, safe to use, smooth to the touch, and odorless. I’m sure you will love it as much as I do.

Order now and see for yourself!

Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Protector

BB Mattress Protector
85%
Rating

Another product that can be called the best mattress cover is this model by Brooklyn Bedding. It is soft, breathable, and waterproof, which is more than enough for a good protector.

Let’s look at its characteristics:

  • The cover fits the majority of mattresses perfectly.
  • The surface of the cover is made of cotton terry, which is soft to the touch and breathable.
  • The waterproof layer doesn’t crinkle or make any other noises.

It is machine washable and won’t be hard to clean.

“A mattress protector can also increase the comfort level of your bed. For instance, if you are sleeping on a foam mattress, which makes you feel hot every night, a breathable protector can help you with temperature regulation during sleep.”

What is really great with that mattress protector?

The worst thing I’ve noticed about this protector is the feel of the material. First of all, it’s rather thin, so if you’re expecting some sort of padding or cushioning, you won’t get it. Moreover, the top cotton layer feels a bit harsh, almost paper-like. Maybe it will become softer after the first wash, but for now, it’s not that plushy.

What is wrong with that mattress protector?

The worst thing I’ve noticed about this protector is the feel of the material. First of all, it’s rather thin, so if you’re expecting some sort of padding or cushioning, you won’t get it. Moreover, the top cotton layer feels a bit harsh, almost paper-like. Maybe it will become softer after the first wash, but for now, it’s not that plushy.

PROS

Waterproof

Machine washable

Fits the majority of mattresses

CONS

Feels thin and a bit harsh

Not an encasement type, which means it won’t protect the mattress from bed bugs

Despite some minor complaints, I am quite happy with this cover. It does its job well, so I’m sure it won’t disappoint you either.

Ready to order? Don’t hesitate and click here!

Nest Bedding Cooling Mattress Protector

Nest Bedding Mattress Protector
85%
Rating

The manufacturer was probably designing this product aiming for it to become the best mattress protector on the market. It is pleasant to the touch and does its job without fail.

Look at its main features:

  • It is made of the combination of polyester, nylon, and thermoplastic polyurethane.
  • It works like a fitted sheet and is suitable for the mattresses up to 18 inches thick.
  • It is machine washable and can be put in the dryer as well.
What is really great with that mattress protector?

The best thing about this protector is the cooling effect. It feels cool even through the sheets. Therefore, if your mattress makes you sleep hot, this cover will help with temperature regulation.

What is wrong with that mattress protector?

The worst thing I’ve noticed about this model is the off-gassing. When I first opened it, it smelled like plastic. I had to wait for approximately two days before actually using it to let the smell air out.

PROS

Waterproof

Soft to the touch, doesn’t make a crinkly sound

Machine washable

Cooling effect

Fits the majority of mattresses (up to 18 inches thick)

CONS

Off-gassing

Might not be warm enough for some users

I must admit:

This top rated waterproof mattress protector managed to impress me. It’s not only waterproof but also cooling, which is a very compelling feature.

Want to test it out? Click here to order!

Bedical Care Superior Mattress Encasement

Bedical Care Mattress Encasement
90%
Rating

This mattress encasement deserves to be called the best mattress protector because it effectively guards all of the sides of the mattress.

Let’s see its main characteristics:

  • It is made of cotton terry and waterproof polyurethane.
  • This model is an encasement, which means it will cover all of the mattress sides and protect the mattress even from bed bugs.
  • The zipper is 3-sided and hidden under the Velcro flap, which also stops the bed bugs from crawling inside.

It is machine washable and won’t cause you any troubles with cleaning.

“If you get cold during the night even under a blanket, a mattress protector might help you deal with this issue. There are many models that include thick layered fabrics or, for example, jacquard, which can help you stay warmer during the night and also add a plush feel to your mattress.”

What is really great with that mattress protector?

The best thing about this cover is its design. The fact that it protects all of the mattress sides is rather reassuring. It will definitely prolong the life of your mattress and create a safe sleeping environment for you without dust mites and other nasty things.

What is wrong with that mattress protector?

The worst thing about this encasement is, again, its design. I know, this sounds quite controversial, so let me explain. While being super protective, this cover is rather hard to put on the mattress because it has to go over each and every side. Also, it might not fit some mattresses 100% perfectly. In my case, (and in other Bedical Care mattress protector reviews) it was a bit roomy.

PROS

Waterproof

Soft and doesn’t make a crinkly noise

Machine washable

An encasement design, great for protection even from bed bugs

Hypoallergenic

CONS

Might be too roomy

The heat levels might not be enough for some users

What can I say? I am quite happy with this mattress encasement. It does its job well and can create a cleaner, safer environment for you to sleep in.

Order here and see for yourself!

Lucid Mattress Protector

Lucid Protector
80%
Rating

Here are its main characteristics:

  • It is made of cotton terry and waterproof Stratosmart Barrier (polyurethane).
  • It can fit the mattresses up to 22 inches thick.
  • It is machine washable.

The manufacturer offers a 15-year warranty.

Here’s what you need to know about it:

  • The blanket comes in 9 sizes.
  • It is made of soft and plush polyester.
What is really great with that mattress protector?

The absolute best thing about this mattress is the fact that it really works. It just doesn’t let the liquid go through. And it gets better: while being 100% waterproof, it doesn’t feel like plastic and doesn’t make that crinkly sound. To me, it’s a win-win!

What is wrong with that mattress protector?

The worst thing that I’ve noticed about this cover is the fact that its sides aren’t waterproof. This can become a big deal for people whose pets sometimes cause “accidents” or, for instance, whose small children like to crawl into the bed with their juice or water.

PROS

100% waterproof top

Machine washable

Soft to the touch

Doesn’t make a crinkly sound

Hypoallergenic

CONS

The sides aren’t waterproof

Not an encasement type, which means it won’t protect the mattress from bed bugs

In general, I am pretty happy with this cover’s performance. I’m sure it will effectively protect your mattress from major spills as long as those occur on the top of the protector.

Feel like this option is great for you? Click here to order!

SafeRest Premium Mattress Protector

SafeRest Mattress Protector
80%
Rating

This protector can easily be called the best mattress cover for a number of reasons. It works, it is easy to clean, and it fits onto almost any mattress without fuss.  

Take a look at its main features:

  • It is made of cotton and polyurethane, which allows it to retain liquids while being soft and pleasant to the touch.
  • It features a fitted sheet design and is suitable for mattresses up to 18 inches thick.
  • The manufacturer offers a 10-year warranty.

It is machine washable, which makes the cleaning process fuss-free.

What is really great with that mattress protector?

The best thing about this mattress cover is a simple fact that it works. The surface of the cover won’t let the liquid leak through, which means you can feel safe about your mattress and its lifespan.

What is wrong with that mattress protector?

The worst thing about this protector is the fact that it’s not 100% waterproof. Unfortunately, the elastic sides don’t have that additional polyurethane layer, which means your mattress won’t be 100% protected. It’s not a big deal if you don’t have small kids or pets, but it should be taken into consideration.

PROS

Completely waterproof surface

Doesn’t make a crinkly sound

Machine washable

Easy fit thanks to its design

Hypoallergenic

CONS

The sides aren’t waterproof

Not an encasement model, which means it won’t protect the mattress from bed bugs

“Keep in mind that your mattress protector must be regularly cleaned since it serves to protect the mattress from spills and stains. Therefore, go with a machine washable model as it will be much easier for you to take care of your mattress protector and keep it clean and odorless.”

Despite its minor flaws, this mattress protective cover made a good impression on me. It works and feels nice. Moreover, thanks to its design, trying to fit it onto the mattress won’t cause any troubles for you.

Want to see for yourself? Click here to order!

Something You Should Be on the Alert For

Listen, I know: shopping can either be pleasant or drive you insane. With the mattress covers, the second one is more possible. The number of the mattress protector reviews, specifications, and loud advertisements can overwhelm and even mislead you.

So, while filtering through all that information, pay attention to the most important factors you should consider when looking for the best mattress protector:

  • Size. This criterion is obvious but nonetheless important. Some manufacturers make covers different in size, so, instead of simply ordering a Queen protector for a Queen mattress, read the measurements first. Just to be on the safe side.
  • Breathability. Waterproof covers tend to sleep hot because of that liquid retaining layer. However, some of them allow more breathability than the others. For instance, polyurethane protectors, especially when combined with the cotton or bamboo top layer, are more breathable than the vinyl ones.
  • Design. Mattress protectors can be full encasements or styled like a fitted sheet. If you want protection from bed bugs, an encasement style is the one for you. However, if being waterproof is all you’re expecting from your mattress protector, the fitted sheet type will be more than enough.
  • Washing method. Since a mattress cover is supposed to protect the mattress from stains, it will collect all of them, therefore requiring to be washed regularly. If the materials of the cover don’t allow you to use a washing machine, the cleaning process can turn into a real headache.

Polyurethane VS. Vinyl: Which One Is Better?

I think you won’t be surprised when I say that the most popular materials for mattress protectors are vinyl and polyurethane. Both of them have their benefits and drawbacks. Let’s take a look at the most important ones, and, hopefully, this will help you make up your mind:

  • Vinyl protectors are super reliable, as this material is rather thick and doesn’t allow any liquid leakage. It is also very effective when it comes to stopping the dust mites and the bed bugs. However, vinyl is a rather loud material, which makes a crinkly noise every time you touch it. It’s also not really breathable, so it might make you sleep hot.
  • Polyurethane is thin and noiseless. It is breathable and effectively stops the liquid from leaking. However, being a super thin material, it might allow some leakage after being washed a couple of times.

Conclusion

After testing out more than a dozen of mattress covers, I feel like my mattress has never been more protected. To make you feel the same way, I’m ready to announce the best waterproof protector, which will certainly increase the lifespan of your mattress.

And the most effective one, in my opinion, is the Plushbeds Organic Cotton Mattress Protector. Are you wondering why? It’s simple: this mattress cover is safe to use, has a really pleasant feel, and excellently does its job at protecting the mattress from liquids and stains. With this mattress cover, you don’t have to worry about breakfasts in bed getting out of hand.

Now, what about you? Have you chosen your personal favorite yet? Please share your opinion in the comments.

JOIN US FOR THE REVIEWS
AND monthly giveaways!
*We hate spam as much as you do!

Product links on Happysleepyhead are referral. We get a commission on purchases made through our links. More information in my disclosures.

4 Comments
  • Maria
    Jun 14, 2018 at 9:44 pm

    I cannot tell you what a life-saver mattress protectors are. We have kids and pets and learned the hard way the damage that occurs to a mattress without one. Now we keep a few around to change them regularly. I have to say, my mattress is lasting a lot longer WITH one than the one that didn’t have one!

  • Harvey C.
    Jul 6, 2018 at 10:07 am

    Just purchased plushbed mattress protector not quite long ago, it’s soft has a lovely feel. Am yet to share my experience. I was damn surprised to see it fit my large mattress.
    It’s cool i have a 5-years warranty. All thanks. I hope to enjoy it.

  • Janeth J.
    Jul 8, 2018 at 11:06 am

    The easy-to-wash Brooklyn bedding protector has given me much confidence that no matter what the stain entails, I’ll always get them cleaned.
    Juice stains got me scared previously, but it was quite quick to wash off.

  • Jackson O
    Jul 28, 2018 at 4:12 pm

    Got a good mattress protector. My bedroom has a new and appealing look now. Nest bedding mattress protector has the qualities I so desire in one.

    It’s simply fantastic!

Post a Comment

Pin It on Pinterest