The 7 Best Innerspring Mattresses for Side Sleepers in 2020 – Reviews and Buying Guide

Quick Links

Company name	Type	Layers	Warranty	Trial	Rating
DreamCloud	Innerspring	High-density memory foam base layer; Foam-encased pocketed micro coils; Dense memory foam layer; Supportive memory foam; Natural latex layer; Soft quilted memory foam; Gel-infused memory foam layer; Cashmere blend cover.	Lifetime warranty	365 nights	95%
Winkbeds	Innerspring	2.0″ pillow top 2.5″ foam encased coils 7.5″ high profile coils 2.0″ support foam	10 years	101 nights	95%
Avocado	Innerspring + latex	Base support core (fabric-encased coil system); Double latex layer; Wool padding; Cotton cover.	25 year warranty	100 nights	90%
Saatva	Innerspring	0,5”Memory foam 4”Coils in foam 7”Steel coils 5” Support foam	15 years	120 nights	90%
Bloom by Brooklyn Bedding	Innerspring	Tencel Stretch Knit Cover 2-inch Gel Memory Foam 2.5-inch Individually Wrapped Microcoils 2-inch Airlux Foam 8-inch Individually Wrapped Base Coils	25 years	120 nights	88%
Modway Jenna	Innerspring	quilted polyester cover 1” responsive foam 0.9” convoluted foam felt liner 7.2” individually wrapped coils	1 year	Not specified	85%
Aviya Mattress	Innerspring	1" layer of high-density breathable comfort foam 3" thick foam 15-gauge steel coils 1" thick stability layer	10 years	100 nights	85%

Editor’s Choice – Best Innerspring Mattress for Side Sleepers

It combines the most popular materials (coils, foam, latex, and even gel) and brings out their best features. This bed is very nicely crafted, feels very comfortable, and has a unique feel. Combined with a lifetime warranty and an extra-long trial period, this model deserves to be called the top-rated innerspring mattress.

Best Durability

Winkbeds is a young company who dares to provide you the exceptional mattress which is able to compete successfully with other producers due to their high-quality materials. This model can easily be considered one of the best innerspring mattress for people who sleep on the side thanks to its comfort layer. It offers a generous amount of cradling and gently hugs the shoulders and the hips, allowing for pressure relief and superb comfort.

Excellent Natural Innerspring Mattress

If you appreciate sleeping on safe and natural mattresses, this model is definitely suited for you. Avocado features only the “green” components, which means it’s all natural and non-toxic. It is also very nicely constructed and comes in two firmness options (the second one features an extra pillow-top).

Best Luxury Innerspring Mattress

Saatva mattress is included in this list because of it is an ultra-premium brand with a coil-on-coil system incorporating memory foam. When buying this mattress, you can be sure that even though it’s reasonably priced, you will still be able to enjoy great comfort levels. Saatva is very nicely made and has a smart combination of layers. 

Best for Cooler Sleep

For those who are tired of waking up sweaty, I’ve got this mattress by Brooklyn Bedding. It has breathable construction, which is additionally enhanced by natural materials for even more refreshing sleep.

Best Cheap Innerspring Mattress

The next option I want to present to you in my review of the best innerspring mattresses for side sleepers is the Jenna by Modway. Its main advantage is the low price, which, however, doesn’t mean that you’ll get a low-quality bed that will start to poke you with springs within the first year of use. The Jenna is made of high-grade materials and features thoughtful design, so you may expect proper spine support and incredible comfort during sleep.

Great Value for Money

Aviya has all the chances to become your most favorite bed. This innerspring mattress is affordable, comes in different firmness options, and offers great comfort levels. This is a luxury mattress, which costs like a regular one. And here’s the kicker:

Because there are different firmness options available, Aviya is suitable for all sleeping positions.

To me, that’s a great set of awesome features.

Factors We Look At

Innerspring mattresses aren’t for everyone, but we know that there are people who can really appreciate this mattress type. And to help those people with the search for the best model, we do our own research and testing.

Here are the factors we consider when looking for the best innerspring mattresses:

• Coil type, count, and gauge. Pocketed, offset, bonnell, and other types of coils have a bit different feel and show different performances. We try to test them the best we can to figure out which construction option feels the best for various sleepers.
• Firmness. A mattress can have a different feel when used by different people. That’s why we pay close attention to each model’s firmness levels and figure out how it feels for different sleepers.
• Durability. Innerspring mattresses are considered to be the least durable beds out there. However, we want you to enjoy your comfortable sleep for a long time, so we search for the most durable, well-made mattresses.
• Noise levels. Coils can be really noisy, that’s a fact. We do our best to find the quietest models, the ones that will not annoy you. And even if we recommend a noisy mattress, we do that only because we believe that its good qualities can compensate for this small issue (and hope that super light sleepers will not use this mattress).
• Trial. When you have a chance to test your new mattress at home and then return it without a problem, this gives you the freedom to find the perfect model for your personal needs and preferences.
• Warranty. As long as your mattress is covered by the warranty, you don’t have to worry about any defects popping out of nowhere. You know that the manufacturer will take care of them.
• Reviews. Different beds don’t work equally well for different users. Therefore, we always pay attention to what other sleepers have to say about certain mattresses. This helps us see the whole picture of how a mattress performs and feels.

FAQ for Innerspring Mattress Buyers

Which innerspring mattress is the best?

Obviously, there isn’t the right answer to this question. We’re all different, and each of us requires something different for their comfort. However, I could surely tell you that all the models I’ve reviewed in this guide are suitable for most average sleepers.

Are pocketed coils better than a solid spring block?

It depends on what you’re expecting from your mattress. If you need more precise contouring and balanced motion response, go for pocketed coils. If you want a sturdier construction with durable edges — an essential thing for couples — then a one-piece coil system may be a better choice.

How long does an innerspring mattress last?

Generally, innerspring beds last between 7 and n10 years; it depends on the quality of materials, the load you put on a mattress, and how actively you utilize it.

What’s the difference between innerspring and hybrid?

The main difference between a hybrid and an innerspring bed lies in the number of comfort layers. In a hybrid, you can see up to 5-8 various comfort layers above the spring block, which results in a balanced feel, while an innerspring bed can only offer just a couple of top layers.

Does an innerspring mattress sag?

Well, every bed may sag over time, and innersprings are no exception. Still, they are sturdier and more uniform than many memory foam beds. You can prolong the life of your mattress by using a box spring.

Innerspring Mattresses and Their Types

You already know that innerspring mattresses are the oldest type of bed. But don’t assume that they are all the same, simple and ordinary. There are many different types of innerspring beds, and we are going to learn about some of them.

Spring mattresses can be divided into these types according to the coils used in their construction. They include:

• Pocketed coils. These coils are individually wrapped (in fabric, usually, but there are some models with foam-encased coils). This type offers a wider response range and tends to provide a plush-firm feel. These coils are also rather contouring and good at motion isolation. However, they might not be that durable, especially in cheaper models.
• Bonnell coils. These have an hourglass shape, with the middle section being thinner. Mattresses with such coils are usually quite inexpensive and come in a wide variety of firmness levels. However, they are not durable, with a lifespan of around 3-5 years.
• Offset coils. This type is characterized by a rather special structure, which results in higher-quality coils. It features a combination of larger coils and smaller wires, which are hinged on the top. Such a build can withstand a lot of weight better than other coil types. It’s more durable but more expensive too.
• Continuous coils. A simple continuous wire is made into rows, which are attached using helicals. That’s what continuous coils are. They are simple, cheap, and offer a rather firm support. They work great with thick comfort layers and are good at motion isolation. At the same time, continuous coils aren’t that good at contouring.
• Microcoils. They are usually used in the comfort layers, alongside with other coil types. Microcoils are made of thinner and very flexible wires, which allows them to offer pressure relief and the ability to adapt to your body shape. They are also cheaper than other comfort layer materials (foam or latex, for instance) and can be very durable. However, they are pricier than other coil types, so such mattresses aren’t the best option for people on a tight budget.

“You will also see the term “coil gauge”. It determines the thickness of the metal (wire), which is used to form a coil. Typically, you see the numbers 12-15, but there are options with thinner coils (for instance, 18-gauge ones). The bigger the number, the softer your mattress will feel. So, if you need a firm model, go with a 12-gauge one. If you need something softer but bouncy, a 14-gauge option would probably work for you.”

Benefits of Innerspring Mattresses

Even though innerspring mattresses aren’t the most popular option today, they still have some cool things to offer. In fact, there are many benefits of sleeping on an innerspring mattress, including:

• Great bounce and response. Innerspring mattresses don’t make their users feel stuck inside the material. On the contrary: with a spring bed, you sleep on it, not in it (unlike memory foam). And a lot of users appreciate this feature very much. The bounciness of the springs also makes it easier for users to shift and change their position during the night. Plus, such fast responsiveness of the material is great for sex.
• A wide range of models to choose from. Because spring mattresses used to be the most popular ones for many years, many manufacturers learned how to make various beds with different levels of firmness and support (and with a different feel overall). That’s why we have a huge number of models to pick from.
• Suitable for all budgets. Seriously, there are innerspring mattresses for any budget. You can find models as cheap as $200. Of course, the luxurious ones also exist and can cost $2,000. So, no matter how much money you have, there’s definitely an innerspring mattress that will work for your wallet.
• No off-gassing. Unlike memory foam, innerspring mattresses don’t have a harsh odor upon arrival. They usually don’t have any off-gassing at all. Some models may have that “new mattress” smell, but that’s it.
• Strong edge support. The reinforced edges offer users a wider sleeping area. This makes innerspring mattresses ideal for couples or people who tend to roll over to the sides of the bed during the night.
• Breathable and cooling. Coil systems allow air to circulate between and inside them easily. This means you will not sleep hot on an innerspring mattress, that’s for sure.

Drawbacks of Innerspring Mattresses

I think you realize that there is no perfect mattress. At least no perfect for everyone. Each type has its own drawbacks, and innerspring is not an exception.

So, while offering some great features, innerspring mattresses have the following flaws:

• Firmness. Because innerspring beds don’t offer you that hugging, cradling feel, they oftentimes seem to be too firm for some users.
• Average contouring. Again, because a spring mattress does not hug, it cannot provide you with superb contouring, which means its pressure and pain relieving properties are below average.
• Sagging. This isn’t a secret: spring beds become saggy after years of usage. They also have the shortest lifespan among other bed types and usually serve their users for around 5-6 years (hence the affordable pricing, I suppose).
• Noise. This feature can annoy many users, and honestly, I understand why. Coils might make a squeaky noise every time you move on the mattress and may even disturb you during sleep. Of course, modern manufacturers come up with new ways to make the coils less noisy, so not all models are that bad.

Is Innerspring Really for You?

Here’s the deal:

I understand that innerspring might not be for everyone. However, I also know that there are many sleepers who might really, really love an innerspring bed.

So, let’s see, whom this mattress type is the most suited for. Innerspring mattresses are for you if you:

• Appreciate a good bounce. Innerspring mattresses offer a fast response, so if you want that bouncy feel, this type is perfect for you.
• Prefer a more traditional feel. In my humble opinion, spring beds have the most traditional feel. Classic, if you will.
• Hate sleeping hot. Coil systems allow the air to circulate freely, which means innerspring mattresses do not sleep hot. Additionally, they don’t hug you (like memory foam, for example), which means no extra warmth and a more restful sleep.
• Don’t mind buying a new mattress every 5 years. I mean, nothing can compare to sleeping on a brand new, “fresh” mattress. So why not allow yourself to do that more often? Especially given the fact that innerspring mattresses aren’t that expensive. Which brings us to the next point…
• Want a budget-friendly bed. Again, spring beds come in various designs and for different prices. They can be as cheap and $200, so there’s definitely an option for you if you have a tight budget.
• Don’t need much contouring. If you have hurting joints or even worse, arthritis, innerspring mattresses aren’t for you. However, if you don’t need that cradling and sinkage, you’re good to go.
• Hate the feeling of being stuck in the mattress. If you prefer to kind of float on top of your mattress, then innerspring is definitely suited for you.

What are your thoughts on innerspring beds? And have you already picked your favorite one? Let us know in the comments!

Additional Resources:

Best Mattresses On the Market – Reviews & Buying Guide

Best Soft Mattresses in 2020

The 8 Best Memory Foam Mattresses in 2020 – Reviews

The 7 Best Hybrid Mattresses in 2020 – Reviews

Product links on Happysleepyhead are referral. We get a commission on purchases made through our links at no additional cost to you. More information in my disclosures.